What are you looking for today?

Bell, Jordan (2023) Cardiometabolic Responses to Same-Session Concurrent Exercise Training, Incorporating High-intensity Interval Training (HIIT), in Overweight and Obesity. Doctoral thesis, The University of Sunderland.

Document

Abstract

Abstract

The majority of adults in England are classified as overweight or obese, with sedentary behaviours a contributing factor to an ever-increasing prevalence. Regular exercise and physical activity can combat obesity-related ill-health, with benefits sought from both cardiovascular- and strength-based exercise. As such, both exercise types are included in exercise guidelines, though few individuals meet recommendations. Same-session Concurrent exercise Training (CT) may be the most time-efficient manner to complete both exercise types. The incorporation of High-Intensity Interval Training (HIIT) as the cardiovascular component may further maximise time efficiency and physiological benefit. A review of the literature revealed that it was key to establish a feasible CT protocol, with an enjoyable and repeatable HIIT protocol with low between-subject variations in the intensity of exercise achieved. In respect to obesity-related health outcome measures, CT was evidenced to provide a wealth of beneficial adaptations to a wide range of cardiometabolic health factors, with body composition changes the primary outcome sought by individuals engaging in exercise interventions. Therefore, we aimed to; 1) synthesise the current evidence-base on the utility and effect of CT as an exercise mode for individuals with obesity, particularly including the use of HIIT and the common methodologies employed; 2) determine the efficacy, reliability and feasibility of using individualised HIIT designs, for more accurate prescription of HIIT for individuals with obesity; 3) establish the feasibility and evaluate the intervention fidelity of completing combined HIIT and RT exercise training programmes in overweight and obese persons; and 4) determine the use and effectiveness of CT compared to HIIT on improving cardiometabolic outcomes in individuals with obesity. A systematic review and meta-analysis of CT programmes in overweight and obesity alongside a test-retest reliability study for a HIIT protocol and an 8-week exercise training feasibility study were undertaken. Meta-analysis revealed that CT could improve body composition, though the true effect of reductions in body mass (MD -1.7kg, 95% CI: -3.6, 0.1) were unclear. CT was effective in improving components of cardiometabolic health, but little research examined the effect of including HIIT. We show that a 10 x 60 second HIIT protocol dosed at an intensity of 80% delta was both repeatable and reliable, with typical error of internal load (VO2 2.2%, HR 2.8%) considerably lower than RPE (9.1%). We also demonstrate 8-week CT and HIIT exercise training programmes with good intervention fidelity and low between-subject variations in heart rate (0.03 & 0.02 beats.min-1). The 8-week CT programme incorporating HIIT was feasible, enjoyable and well-adhered to with low rates of adverse events in overweight and obese males. Moreover, CT caused greater reductions in body mass (MD: 2.0kg 95% CI: -0.7, 4.6) than HIIT-only, alongside greater improvements in LV EDV (MD 21.55ml 95% CI: 8.72, 34.38) and other factors including strength. However, the observed changes are unclear, with a small sample size and wide confidence intervals demonstrating uncertainty in the true effect and whether this is a meaningful change. This work requires further investigation, though, it is clear that focus should be given to cardiometabolic health more generally, rather than a sole emphasis on weight loss from exercise interventions.

Item Type: Thesis (Doctoral)
Depositing User: Delphine Doucet
URI: https://sure.sunderland.ac.uk/id/eprint/16806

Further Details

More Information

Depositing User

Identifiers

Item ID
16806

Users with ORCIDS

Catalogue record

Date Deposited
17 Nov 2023 13:51
Last Modified
02 Jun 2025 14:53

Contributors

Author
Jordan Bell

University Divisions

Subjects

Actions (login required)

View Item (Repository Staff Only)

Downloads per month over past year