Abstract

This reimagining of the research landscape surrounding autistic mental distress is rooted in a Marxist, materialist sociology, as exemplified by Chapman (2023). This perspective aims to scrutinize the flaws and limitations of psych-plaining, a term used in relation to autistic people by Milton (2025) to describe the invalidation experienced by autistic individuals, who often face unique challenges and adversities in their daily lives due to the neuro-normative society.
Disbelief of autistic everyday experiences of adversity can lead to distress and overwhelm (Lewis and Stevens, 2023; McQuaid et al., 2022; Merrington et al., 2024; Petty et al., 2024). Developing from this insight away from discourse about increased mental distress being merely about everyday stress (e.g., McGorry et al. 2024; Hagopian, 2025) due to being a particularly harmful narrative resulting in epistemic injustice. Autistic individuals are already marginalized and misunderstood by society (Botha et al., 2022), and furthering this could be damaging. By highlighting the importance of listening to and valuing the narratives of autistic individuals, this approach seeks to challenge and dismantle these harmful practices.
Their narratives, whether accurate or not, remain impactful and reflect their lived experiences. The adversities stemming from pathological conceptualizations, which portray autistic individuals as devalued and unproductive citizens, are common experiences (e.g., Branton et al., 2023; Grinker, 2020). These conceptualizations contribute to the stigmatization and marginalization of autistic individuals, further exacerbating their social suffering.
Exploring this topic could significantly advance the sociology of mental health by elaborating on key ideas and applying them to a population that is already marginalized. By doing so, it aims to foster a more inclusive and equitable understanding of mental distress and well-being for all individuals.