What are you looking for today?

Davis, Paul and Edwards, L. (2015) The new IOC and IAAF policies on female eligibility: old emperor, new clothes? Sport, Ethics and Philosophy, 8 (1). pp. 44-56. ISSN 1751-1321

Document

  • [thumbnail of Davis  Edwards IOC  IAAF Rules.pdf]
    Davis Edwards IOC IAAF Rules.pdf - Published Version

Abstract

Abstract

The Caster Semenya debacle touched off by the 2009 Berlin World Athletics Championships resulted finally in IOC and IAAF abandonment of sex testing, which gave way to procedures that make female competition eligibility dependent upon the level of serum testosterone, which must be below the male range or instrumentally countered by androgen resistance. We argue that the new policy is unsustainable because (i) the testosterone-performance connection it posits is uncompelling; (ii) testosterone-induced female advantage is not ipso facto unfair advantage; (iii) the new policy reflects the gender policing impulses endemic to sport as well as the broader cultural impulses to monstrify women and to doctor women who have nothing wrong with them; (iv) female–male performance disparities are not the only reason for sex-segregated sport, but co-exist with respectable cultural and practical reasons, which (v) provide a powerful case for allowing athletes to compete in the sex category congruent with their gender identity.

Item Type: Article
Depositing User: Paula Normington
URI: https://sure.sunderland.ac.uk/id/eprint/6294

Further Details

More Information

Depositing User

Identifiers

Item ID
6294
Identification Number
ISSN
1751-1321

Users with ORCIDS

ORCID for Paul Davis

Catalogue record

Date Deposited
10 May 2016 08:44
Last Modified
26 Nov 2025 09:08

Actions (login required)

View Item (Repository Staff Only)

Downloads per month over past year